Skip to main content

Real Presence

 On April 15 on this year (2019), the Cathedral of Notre Dame in Paris burst into flames.  As the fire was blazing on the roof of this remarkable church, imperiling the entire structure and the life anyone who entered, the chaplain of the Paris fire brigade, Father Jean-Marc Fournier, rushed in.  I want to share with you in his own words what he did and why:


As soon as I arrived, there were two things that it struck me as absolutely essential to recover: firstly, the invaluable treasure that is the Crown of Thorns, then, of course, Jesus, present in the Blessed Sacrament.  Everyone understands that the Crown of Thorns is this precious, extraordinary relic, but the Blessed Sacrament is our Lord made flesh... you'll understand it's difficult to see someone you love perish in flames.

He describes standing alone in the cathedral "surrounded by flames, fire and smoldering objects falling from the ceiling" as he rescued this relic and the consecrated Eucharist.[1]  Can you imagine?  You may think, how could anyone possibly risk their life for the Eucharist?  There are more than 200,000 Catholic parishes in the world and more than 400,000 priests, most with mass offered daily.  By that measure, the Eucharist is not exactly a scarce commodity.  While this is true, each of those altars and tabernacles carries the real body of our Lord made flesh, as Fr. Fournier said.  It is not scarce, but is incredibly precious—indeed, the most precious thing in the world—yet offered to all who come, free of charge, every day.  If it is worth rushing into a fire to rescue, isn’t it worth us going to mass to receive? 

    Why should we believe in the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist as Catholics understand it?  Every Christian makes decisions on which of Jesus’ words to take literally and which to take figuratively or ‘spiritually.’  St. Francis, for example, read Matthew 19:21, in a way that few of us are willing or able to: “sell your possessions, give to the poor …then, come follow me.”  A key passage that Catholics (and Orthodox) have taken very seriously and indeed, literally for two thousand years of history is John 6:53, “Unless you eat my body and drink my blood, there is no life in you.” 

            In this so-called Bread of Life discourse (John 6), Jesus had every opportunity to explain that he was speaking figuratively, but again and again he doubles and triples down on the unequivocal meaning of actually ‘gnawing’ on his flesh and consuming his blood: “For my flesh is true food, and my blood is true drink.  Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood remains in me and I in him” (6:55-56) [see Grodi for the ‘winnowing effect’ in this discourse].  Jesus himself makes strong, repeated statements about the real identification of the bread and wine with his body and blood and his continued presence in the breaking of the bread whenever it is celebrated.  This is a profoundly Biblical idea that is prefigured by the Exodus and temple sacrifices.  I do not have space to develop those ideas here.

            The belief in the Real Presence was held by the earliest followers of Jesus—see the Didache, Ignatius of Antioch, Polycarp, and Justin Martyr—people who knew the Apostles.  They saw in the Last Supper and their encounter at Emmaus an injunction to celebrate the Eucharist and to ‘discern the body’ present there, as Paul instructs in 1st Corinthians. 

            This belief has continued to be held by all Christians for fifteen centuries, until Protestant reformers challenged it in Western Christianity.  I think the onus is actually on Protestants to demonstrate that it is not the authentic belief and practice of Christ and His Church.



[1]Willis, Ella and Ailbhe Rea, “Revealed: hero fire brigade chaplain paused to give a blessing as he rescued priceless relics from Notre Dame flames.” Daily Standard. 17 April 2019 https://www.standard.co.uk/news/world/revealed-hero-fire-brigade-chaplain-paused-to-give-a-blessing-as-he-rescued-priceless-relics-from-a4120501.html

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Jesus' Hard Sayings

                          Jesus’ Hard Sayings  Twenty First Sunday in Ordinary Time Cycle B  August 19/20, 2021 https://bible.usccb.org/bible/readings/082221.cfm Good morning / afternoon, St. Agnes. It’s been a long first full week of classes for me—and I am sure for all of you who are parents, teachers, and students. I just started my 17th year as a teacher. [This is my first at Assumption High School where I teach Theology]. I have been reflecting this month on an early experience I had as a student teacher preparing for my first classroom. I was up at the University of Notre Dame in an Education class. The professor was legendary educator named Dr. Thomas Doyle who everyone called “Doc.” He grouped all of us student-teachers by subject matter around tables. So, I was working on a problem with several other new Theology teachers when Doc came to talk to us. He said something I’ll never forget: “You The...

His Eye is On the Sparrow

  Why should I feel discouraged / Why should the shadows come / Why should my heart feel lonely / And long for heaven and home / When Jesus is my portion / A constant friend is He / His eye is on the sparrow / And I know He watches over me / I sing because I'm happy / I sing because I'm free / His eye is on the sparrow / And I know He watches me “His Eye is On the Sparrow,”  Civilla D. Martin and Charles H. Gabriel    For several years I was a parishioner at a predominately Black Catholic parish in Oklahoma.  Of the many things I loved about this community, the gorgeous music sung by the Gospel choir every Sunday stood out.  They sang a range of songs from Negro spirituals to contemporary hymns more familiar in predominately white parishes.  My favorite is the hymn above, “His Eye is On the Sparrow.”    The house sparrow is one of the most common animals in the world—so familiar and so small that it is easy to ignore. ...

Envisioning a World that Has Never Existed

  “In every age, no matter how cruel the oppression carried on by those in power, there have been those who struggled for a different world. I believe this is the genius of humankind, the thing that makes us half divine: the fact that some human beings can envision a world that has never existed.”        ~ Anne Braden (1924-2006), Louisville racial justice activist   Anne Braden was a local white advocate in the Civil Rights movement in the 1950s and ‘60s.  She and her husband Carl are most famous for purchasing a house in the then exclusively white neighborhood of Shively for a Black couple.  Both Bradens were arrested as “Communists’ for their act and the house was dynamited after irate neighbors shot it up and burned a cross in the front yard. Anne was not deterred and continued the fight for the remaining fifty years of her life, founding a newspaper and several antiracist organizations.      Anne provides an exce...